Most people were justifiably outraged when Judge Jean Boyd of Texas “sentenced” a young man responsible for the deaths of 4 people and leaving 2 more brain damaged to a posh treatment spa for 1 year, instead of the 20 years in jail recommended by prosecutors. The defense of “affluenza” – a made-up psychological condition not in any diagnostic manual – was successful and the families of the human beings slaughtered by Ethan Couch, a 16 year old driving drunk were victimized a second time.

You have to feel broken hearted for the families of the victims. Justice was their only consolation and justice was denied by Judge Boyd, who may have been a better argument for affluenza. There is little one can say about this miscarriage of justice, except perhaps to point out that the poor, and especially African-Americans suffer this type of injustice on a regular basis. One need not ask “what if Couch were black?” because Judge Boyd has a record in this regard. Just last year she sentenced a 14 year old African-American boy to 12 years in jail for punching a man once which resulted in his death. One cannot deny that killing any human being should result in punishment, nor can one deny that punishments are not the same when your family has money.

Judge Jean Boyd was no doubt elected to office and is just the kind of judge the Chamber of Commerce would endorse and help fund. Money corrupts the justice system just as easily as the political system, one only need look to the Michigan Supreme Court and its sterling record of ruling in favor of corporations over individuals 90% of the time for a more local example.

It’s sad, but true that in a sense our justice system is suffering from affluenza.   

4 Responses to Affluenza

  1. One thing that occurred to me some time ago: People who were against euthanasia trashed Jack Kevorkian and even accused him of enjoying watching people die. Imagine how much worse his vilification would have been if had been black. Please note I’m talking about unconscious bias. With conscious bias? Even worse yet.

  2. Rex A. Umney says:

    Its just a matter of perception. If you were the parents of the defendant you might be more inclined to agree with the defense.

    If, however, you lost someone close to you, then you would lean more towards the State.

    It is an example of how money and a good attorney can go a long way.

    Your racist overtones about “What if he were black” only serve to put a foul odor in the room. OJ Simpson was black and he got away with what some feel was Murder. What if he had been white and of a lower income?

    My condolences to the families of the recently departed, but if you pull your head from your ass long enough you might see not everything has to be about race. Eddy Murphy is funny when he does it, but you’re no Eddy Murphy, Mr. Fieger.

  3. Irvin A. Mermelstein says:

    Mr. Fieger,

    I’m sorry to be off topic, but I was told by a another lawyer here that there were some flooding cases in Westland MI some time ago and that your firm may have talked to some homeowners there about flooding.

    If you or whoever at your firm was involved (if the flooding information is accurate) could respond, I would be very grateful. I can be reached by email at

    Thanks very much.

  4. Rex A. Umney says:

    I haven’t seen anything new since last year so I figured I would use the last post of the year to wish everyone a happy New Year 2014!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: